Good Cop, Bad Cop: Why Polarised Parenting Backfires
As parents, it is natural to want what’s best for our children. We love them fiercely, and we want what’s best for them, but sometimes our reactions swing too far in opposite directions.
One moment we are stern and demanding, the next moment we are soft and lenient. This habit, often described as polarised parenting, can look like the best strategy, but research shows it can actually undermine the goals we are trying to achieve.
Polarised parenting reflects extreme swings between strict discipline and permissive leniency without finding a balanced middle ground. It is the parenting equivalent of playing the “good cop, bad cop” every day. But children don’t thrive in inconsistency; they need both limits and warmth to grow into emotionally secure and confident adults.
The undertone of consistency
Diana Baumrind, a renowned developmental psychologist, identified parenting styles that impact children’s growth. Her research highlights authoritative parenting, which combines clear rules with warmth as the most effective. In contrast, authoritarian, permissive and inconsistent parenting are linked to poorer outcomes. Studies show children raised under authoritative approaches report higher life satisfaction, better self-regulation and stronger social skills.
Inconsistent discipline is particularly damaging. Research indicates that children experiencing unpredictable parenting are more likely to struggle with anxiety, emotional regulation and social relationships. One study in Nigeria found that adolescents exposed to inconsistent parenting had significantly lower self-esteem.
Why polarised parenting fails
First, it erodes trust. Children need predictable responses to feel secure. When reactions swing from anger to indulgence, children may become anxious or withdrawn.
Second, it weakens self-discipline. Consistent boundaries help children internalise rules. Without them, children may behave well only when closely monitored, not because they understand the values behind the rules.
Third, it affects long-term relationships. Children raised in an inconsistent environment may struggle with communication and emotional regulation later in life.
Another reason is that it confuses expectations. Children cannot anticipate consequences when rules constantly change.
None of this suggests that parents must be perfect. Every household has moments of frustration and moments of flexibility. The key difference is consistency. A balanced approach provides children with both guidance and security.
Polarised parenting may be a quick fix in the heat of the moment, but over time, it creates instability rather than strength. Children do not need extremes; they need steady leadership, clear expectations and the reassurance that love does not fluctuate with behaviour.
In the end, effective parenting is less about playing “good cop or bad cop” and more about being a consistent guide.
For more on parenting and family, click HERE to join our WhatsApp channel and find the latest!
