Why Some Kids Thrive on Strict Rules and Others Fall Apart
In the complex tapestry of childhood, we often see two seemingly contradictory reactions to structure: one child flourishes under clear, consistent boundaries, while another wilts under the very same pressure. Why does one child seem to find security in strict rules, becoming disciplined and successful, while another feels stifled, leading to rebellion, anxiety, or low self-esteem?
The answer isn’t a one-size-fits-all formula, but rather an interplay of temperament, the nature of the rules, and, most importantly, the relationship in which those rules are enforced.
Structure as security
For some children, strict rules provide a vital sense of predictability and safety. This is often true for children with certain temperaments:
The anxious and highly sensitive child: A world without boundaries can feel chaotic and overwhelming. Clear rules reduce the constant need to test limits and make decisions. The rules become an external organising force that calms their internal worry.
The concrete thinker: These children often struggle with ambiguity and abstract concepts. Strict rules, clearly defined and consistently enforced, provide concrete guidelines for expected behaviour. They know precisely what success looks like and how to achieve it.
The child seeking control: While it sounds counterintuitive, for a child who feels a lack of control in other areas of life, mastering a clear set of rules can be incredibly empowering. They own the process of meeting the expectation, which builds competence and self-efficacy.
The key difference for these children is that the rules are perceived as support that helps them reach higher, rather than a cage that restricts their movement.
Pressure and perceived threat
On the other side of the coin, strict rules can be profoundly damaging. This reaction is often rooted in a different internal makeup and a different kind of rule enforcement:
The independent and highly expressive child: This child’s core need is often for autonomy and self-determination. Excessive, rigid rules feel like an attack on their personality and their right to make choices. Their falling apart is often expressed as rebellion, defiance, or intense power struggles.
The child whose self-worth is tied to performance: When strict rules are tied to parental approval and love, the consequences of failure become devastating. The child operates under constant fear of disappointment, leading to intense anxiety, perfectionism, burnout, and, eventually, a breakdown when they inevitably fail to meet an impossible standard.
The creative and divergent thinker: For the child who sees multiple ways to solve a problem or prefers unconventional approaches, overly strict methods stifle their natural inclination. They may disengage or appear lazy because their unique method is constantly invalidated by the rigid system.
The missing ingredient…
The critical variable that determines which path a child takes is not the strictness of the rules, but the context and intention behind them.
Rules with empathy
The thriving child receives rules framed by love and understanding. The parent says, “No screens after dinner because your growing brain needs good sleep, and I want you to feel your best.” The boundary is clear, and the rationale is rooted in care.
The child who falls apart often experiences rules as punishment or control, with no empathic explanation or room for conversation.
Rules with flexibility
Rules must be appropriate for the child’s developmental stage. Strictness that respects a child’s evolving competence like allowing a teenager more control than a toddler, leads to success.
Strictness that treats a 16-year-old like a 6-year-old erodes their sense of competence and fosters resentment.
Rules with connection
When a child messes up, the child A’s parent uses it as a teaching moment to reconnect and problem-solve. The child who falls apart is often met with shame and isolation. This teaches them that failure means a withdrawal of love, and the pressure becomes unbearable.
Takeaway for parents
The goal of parenting is not simply to create obedient children, but to raise capable humans. If your child is struggling with structure, step back from the rules themselves and examine the relationship.
Audit your “why”: Are your rules helping your child grow, or are they helping you feel in control?
Does your structure align with your child’s personality? A highly independent child may thrive on having two acceptable dinner choices, rather than one mandated meal. Before you enforce a rule, always make sure your child feels seen, heard, and loved. A strong bond is the shock absorber that allows a child to bounce back from the impact of a strict boundary.
Ultimately, the best environment for any child is one where boundaries are clear, expectations are high, and the love is unconditional. It’s the difference between a supportive spine and a crushing weight.
Click HERE to join our WhatsApp Channel for more!
